Abstract
Introduction:
This study examined the validity of tensiometry as an objective method of assessing the improvements in the quality of knots and technical performance due to practice on suturing and knot-tying skills.
Methods:
We evaluated the quality of 1,830 knots produced by undergraduate medical students before training (pre-test), after (post-test), and after a week retention (retention-test) using tensiometry. These results were compared to expert-based assessments of products and performance.
Results:
Tensiometry, as well as expert-based assessments can detect changes in the quality of knots and technical performance from pre to post and retention-test ( p<0.05). However, these three methods may assess different dimensions of the same products and actions.
Conclusions:
The development of trainee evaluation criteria for the acquisition of surgical skills is a crucial element in surgical education. Based on our patterns of results it is hypothesized that tensiometry can serve as an economic first approximation of the quality of knots and suturing performance.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Aggarwal R., Hance J., Darzi A. (2004). Surgical education and training in the new millennium. Surgical Endoscopy and other Interventional Technique. 18(10):1409–1410
Bann S.D., Khan M.S., Darzi A.W. (2003). Measurement of surgical dexterity using motion analysis of simple bench tasks. World Journal of Surgery 27(4):390–394
Cusimano M.D., Cohen R., Tucker W., Murnaghan J., Kodama R., Reznick R. (1994). A comparative analysis of the costs of administration of an OSCE (objective structured clinical examination). Academic Medicine 69(7): 571–576
Datta V., Chang A., Mackay S., Darzi A. (2002). The relationship between motion analysis and surgical technical assessments. American Journal of Surgery 184(1):70–73
Dubrowski A., Sidhu R., Park J., Carnahan H. (2005). Quantification of motion characteristics and forces applied to tissues during suturing. American Journal of Surgery 190(1):131–136
Hanna G.B., Frank T.G., Cuschieri A. (1997). Objective assessment of endoscopic knot quality. American Journal of Surgery 174(4):410–413
Ind T.E., Shelton J.C., Shepherd J.H. (2001). Influence of training on reliability of surgical knots. British Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology 108(10): 1013–1016
Ivy J.J., Unger J.B., Mukherjee D. (2004). Knot integrity with nonidentical and parallel sliding knots. American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology 190(1):83–86
Kneebone R.L., Scott W., Darzi A., Horrocks M. (2004). Simulation and clinical practice: strengthening the relationship. Medical Education 38(10):1095–1102
Martin J.A., Regehr G., Reznick R., MacRae H., Murnaghan J., Hutchison C., Brown M. (1997). Objective structured assessment of technical skill (OSATS) for surgical residents. British Journal of Surgery 84(2):273–278
Moorthy K., Munz Y., Sarker S.K., Darzi A. (2003). Objective assessment of technical skills in surgery. British Medical Journal 327(7422): 1032–1037
Nathanson L.K., Nathanson P.D.K., Cuschieri A. (1991). Safety of Vessel Ligation in Laparoscopic Surgery. Endoscopy 23(4):206–209
Reznick R., Regehr G., MacRae H., Martin J., McCulloch W. (1997). Testing technical skill via an innovative “bench station” examination. American Journal of Surgery 173(3):226–230
Schmidt R.A., Lee T.D. (2005). Motor Control and Learning: A behavioral Emphasis. (3) Human Kinetics, Champaign, IL
Shaw A.D., Duthie G.S. (1995). A simple assessment of surgical sutures and knotsJournal of the Royal College of Surgeons of Edinburgh 40(6):388–391
Silverman J., Wood D.F. (2004). New approaches to learning clinical skills. Medical Education 38(10):1021–1023
Szalay D., MacRae H., Regehr G., Reznick R. (2000). Using operative outcome to assess technical skill. American Journal of Surgery 180(3):234–237
Torkington J., Smith S.G., Rees B., Darzi A. (2001). The role of the basic surgical skills course in the acquisition and retention of laparoscopic skill. Surgical Endoscopy and other Interventional Technique 15(10):1071–1075
Wanzel K.R., Hamstra S.J., Caminiti M.F., Anastakis D.J., Grober E.D., Reznick R.K. (2003). Visual–spatial ability correlates with efficiency of hand motion and successful surgical performance. Surgery 134(5):750–757
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Kyle Leming, J., Dorman, K., Brydges, R. et al. Tensiometry as a Measure of Improvement in Knot Quality in Undergraduate Medical Students. Adv Health Sci Educ Theory Pract 12, 331–344 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10459-006-9005-7
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10459-006-9005-7